|
Home
Canine Multi-Focal Retinopathy — CMR Ron Hiskes, Ph.D. ACQ Spring 2007 Retinal Dysplasia is well known in humans and dogs. The
retina is the nervous layer of the eye, and it normally lies flat against the
back of the eye. The retina is responsible for collecting light impulses which
are then transferred to the brain and interpreted as vision. When the retinas
detach from their normal position, they cease to function and the patient
becomes blind. From the website of ACVO (American College of Veterinary
Ophthalmologists: The retina is the neurological structure in the back of
the eye which receives light and converts it into an electrical signal. This
electrical signal is transmitted to the brain by way of the optic nerve and is
interpreted by the brain as vision. The embryological development of the retina
is quite complex. It forms from a small part of the front of the primitive
neural tube, the structure that becomes the nervous system (brain and spinal
cord) of the adult. Malformations of the retina before birth are rare but can be
due to either hereditary or environmental (in the uterus) influences. Retinal
dysplasia is a type of retinal malformation. The word "dysplasia" simply means
"a defective development of an organ or structure". Retinal dysplasia occurs
when the 2 primitive layers of the retina do not form together properly. Mild
dysplasia manifests as folds in the inner retinal layer. These are called
"retinal folds". In "geographic" retinal dysplasia there are larger areas of
defective retinal development. In the severe form of dysplasia, the 2 retinal
layers do not come together at all and retinal detachment occurs. The cause of retinal dysplasia in most breeds is genetic
although prenatal infections with herpesvirus and parvovirus may also lead to
it. Retinal dysplasia is reported in 25 of the 100 breeds of dogs listed in the
1996 edition of the CERF book Ocular Disorders Presumed to be Hereditary in
Purebred Dogs. Twenty-four of these breeds had retinal folds reported, and 11
had Retinal folds rarely cause vision problems for the
individual dog. They represent small blind spots which are probably not even
noticed by the dog. However, large areas of dysplasia (geographic dysplasia) may
lead to large deficits in the visual field and dogs with retinal detachments are
completely blind. There have been many questions recently about the
certifiability of dogs with retinal folds. Retinal folds may be seen in many
breeds and still pass a CERF examination and receive a CERF number. This is due
to the fact that the condition is thought either not to be hereditary in the
particular breed or has never been shown to be connected to serious (blinding)
forms of dysplasia. In some breeds, particularly Labrador Retrievers, Samoyeds,
and English Springer Spaniels, individuals with retinal folds are NOT given a
CERF number. Since retinal dysplasia is common in these breeds and dogs and
bitches with retinal folds can have puppies with blindness and/or skeletal
problems the gene should not be perpetuated. In all breeds, individuals with
geographic and retinal detachment forms of retinal dysplasia are NOT certifiable In 2003, a condition thought to be Retinal Dysplasia was
seen in the top winning show Coton named Quincy. It was an unusual form and
was called “The Coton Form of Retinal Dysplasia”, consisting of tiny bubbles or
lesions around the periphery of the retina. It was not progressive and didn’t
seem to impair sight. This prompted an investigation by Dr. Grahn at the
University of Saskatchewan to learn more about this condition. ACVO asked ACC
whether or not to classify this condition as “non-breedable”. We replied that
we were not experts and could not tell them what to do. ACVO took the
conservative approach and classified it as “non-breedable”. Subsequently, an
ACC member and Coton breeder, Caroline Brooke, had a couple of her Cotons CERFED
with a similar condition. She collaborated with researchers at the University
of Pennsylvania and prevailed upon her friends and acquaintances to send blood
samples for DNA research. The researchers got lucky. The defective gene was
located at the same spot as in several other breeds they had been researching.
This resulted in a definitive DNA test to determine if a particular Coton was
clear, a carrier or affected. So far 10-20 Cotons have been tested and a few
have been found to be carriers. We ask each of you to help this research by
contributing a blood sample to OptiGen, the organization that is conducting the
tests. We need at least a 100 Cotons tested to begin to do the relevant
statistics to know what percentage of Cotons are carriers.
Fairview Cottage and CMR Research at UPENN Carolyn Brooke ACQ March 2007 with thanks to researchers and all participants ACC member Carolyn Brooke is a retired breeder in
Pennsylvania who has written previously for ACQ about her activities visiting
shut-ins and rest homes with her Cotons. Looking back, it almost seems that we have always been
working with "the eye project" for over 10 years since an essential ingredient
of any Coton breeder's program is an annual CERF eye examination. (Canine Eye
Registration Foundation). While the CERF eye examination is routine for breeding
dogs, the reality of the examination is that, even for our dear Cotons, the
exams can detect potential problems to be excluded or eliminated from a breeding
program. And so for Fairview Cottage, our true realization of the
impact of health tests began in January 1999. Annie of Fairview Cottage (dob
August 1996) was of the breeding age of 2 1/2 years. While our thoughts of
breeding her were still in the planning stage, we had begun our preparations by
completing the health exam, OFA patella certification and moved on to the eye
exam. And then in the darkened examining room of the ophthalmologist, Dr.
Stephen Gross, I heard the words ..." um...this is very interesting".
Interesting is not what I wanted to hear! Additional words "small areas of
linear folds," "focal bullous retinal detachments,"
and "possibly the result of an earlier infection" meant nothing to me
except that my dear Annie had a problem. Then, more concern kicked in and focused on the word
infection; concern and worry for my other "kids" surfaced. Fortunately,
veterinarians are special people for not only do they give their knowledge and
love of animals to help "our kids" but they also understand and appreciate the
anxious concerns of the kids' humans. Dr. Gross was no exception. Despite the
packed waiting room he allowed me to bring in my other 5 dogs for immediate
exams to relieve my anxiety. . .. and all were fine. End of the "eye" story? Well, if you had talked to me back
then, I probably would have said yes. What more could be said? This was an
isolated case. Annie had an eye problem. She was spayed. She has regular eye
exams to monitor and insure her heath. She is living happily ever after as Aunt
Annie, the old maid. Soon I learned that Annie's condition may not have been an
isolated incident. Helga Lopatin, Past President of
USACTC, issued an open letter (March 1999) to owners and breeders about Retinal
Dysplasia (RD) in the Coton. A copy of this letter can be found on the USACTC
website under Health Information. Here too, you can find Dr.
Grauwels' article on Ocular Hereditary Disease. For
a better appreciation and understanding of how far we've come, it is good to
view the beginning research. As the number of "kids" increased at
Fairivew Cottage, it became more practical, and perhaps comical as the
herd of white fluffy dogs emerged from our motor home, to attend CERF Eye
Clinics for the examinations of our dogs. The ophthalmologist in our area who
generally performs the examinations is Dr. Gustav Aquirre.
When we first met Dr. Aguirre, he was working at The Baker Institute, Cornell
University in NY, but would come to suburban Philadelphia, PA (which is actually
his home) on weekends and conduct CERF eye clinics. From the U of Penn website on the eye clinics comes the
following description of his reputation. " Dr. Aguirre is an internationally
recognized ophthalmologist whose clinical and research work has been
instrumental in controlling the major inherited eye diseases in dogs. He and
his research group have developed most of the DNA-based tests that are
currently available to specifically determine the affected, carrier or normal
status of dogs with inherited eye diseases" Hopefully we do learn lessons from our experiences and do
not take anything for granted. In this context it meant including our 13 month
old Flossie in the group for annual CERF exams in 2002 rather than waiting until
she was closer to breeding age. Flossie's exam certainly stopped the steady
flow of examinations at the clinic! For me the emotional electricity in the
darkened exam room became almost stifling; for Dr. Aguirre, ever the researcher,
I think it was exhilarating. He had detected a condition of interest -
Multifocal Retinopathy. Such a condition had been detected in the Great
Pyrenees, but Dr. Aguirre had not seen it in the Coton. If I had been more in tune with the mind of a medical
researcher, I probably would have, at the time, better appreciated Flossie's
condition. In retrospect, Flossie's diagnosis provided an opportunity to become
part of valuable research in Coton eye health. From the CERF screening, Flossie
went to Dr. Gross, the ophthalmologist who had treated Annie, for medical workup
and treatment. (Subsequently I learned that Dr. Gross had been one of Dr.
Aguirre's students) As with Annie, Flossie was spayed and continued her visits
to Dr. Gross. In April of 2003, Dr. Gross felt it would be of benefit for
future studies to have Flossie visit him at U of Penn to photograph her
fundus (the back portion of the eye). Later that
year Flossie again visited Dr. Aguirre, at a CERF clinic, to keep him advised of
her status. By this time I finally realized that the years of eye examinations,
both at Dr. Gross' office and at Dr. Aguirre's CERF clinics, had the potential
to produce a real benefit for the future health of Cotons. In 2004 Dr. Aguirre returned to University of Pennsylvania
fulltime. You may be interested in reading Susan
Finklestein's article, "You Can Go Home Again: Dr. Gus Aguirre Returns
to Penn" in the Fall 2004 issue of The Bellwether. The web
address for that article is:
http://www.vet.upenn.edu/schoolresources/communications/publications/bellwether/60/aguirre.html
By 2005, plans for a project to investigate Canine
Multi-focal Retinopathy were coming together. Dr. Karina
Guziewicz became the lead researcher on "the Coton Study" project. The
aim was to find a DNA based test for the gene causing
multifocal retinopathy in the Coton. Since our Annie and Flossie had
been diagnosed with the eye condition in 1999 and 2002 respectively, Fairview
Cottage became a source for research information. Many different
bloodlines, which represent much of the Coton world, were in our immediate
Fairview family of 15 dogs. The researchers presented me with their "wish list"
for my part of the project. Dr. Aguirre's explanation for the "wish list" was
"we ask for what we would like in hopes to get as much as we need [can get]".
In short form, the initial request was for blood samples, pedigree information,
and copies of last eye exams for all 15 of our dogs at Fairview Cottage. In
increasing and differing degrees, the scope expanded to include any/all
ancesters, offspring, siblings, anyone related and
finally unrelated Cotons. For the first step of our part of the project, Fairview
Cottage's veterinarian, Dr. Anna Edling, drew blood
from our dogs. Vials of blood, pedigrees, eye exam data were delivered to the U
of P researchers. Any dog that did not have a recent exam was taken to Penn for
examination. Additionally both parents of my oldest dog, Casey (dob
1993) and a sibling visited U of Penn for eye examinations and blood samples.
For one line I secured samples from 5 generations. We were well on our way to
providing data for the investigation. After these first steps, it seemed almost impossible for me
to continue. How was I to secure blood samples from the dogs that did not live
with me or in close enough proximity to transport them to my vet. Fortunately
Dr. Guziewicz came to my rescue. Although more
involved and time consuming on her part, she was able to extract the required
DNA information from a cheek swab. Now the project could move again. My
envelopes containing a limited explanation and request for help, instruction
sheets, and brushes for cheek swabs went out to our offspring. Families we knew
who had non-Fairview Cottage Cotons were also asked or offered to help. Other
breeders offered to contribute samples. Our quest for data was moving along,
although slowly. Eventually we were able to provide a substantial number of
samples for the researchers to work with. Since all the breeding dogs had
clear CERF examinations, we could not provide the samples of the offspring of
affected dogs. ( I almost wished we could find an affected dog who had produced
a litter to actually see what the results would have been.) From Fairview
Cottage's contributions, as well as the other samples, we could only show if a
dog was a carrier or non-carrier of the CMR gene. The research conducted by Drs.
Guziewicz and Aguirre with information gathered from many sources,
including the efforts of Fairview Cottage, research in Canada by Dr. Grahn, and
research by Cornell's Dr. Acland (also associated
with U of P's New Bolton Center), has enabled the development of the CMR Test
(Canine Multifocal Retinopathy Test) for the Coton. This year (2007) it was
announced that the screening test for CMR is available through Optigen. At
present this test utilizes blood samples. As I view the test, the most important
product of this screening test is the detection of carriers of the CMR gene so
that breeders can utilize this information to conduct their breeding program
more effectively and with greater knowledge. Responsible breeding is
intelligent breeding. Each scientific advance and discovery is a stepping
stone...a building block for the next piece of knowledge. The CMR test is one
more tool that we now, in 2007, have available to us. Maybe it will also be one
of the steps and tools to accurately detect other problems as well as remedies. As we (all Coton owners and breeders) continue living with
our "kids" we experience more conditions and challenges; more opportunities
become available to contribute to knowledge about the health of our breed. One
of the many benefits of our breed clubs is the ability to bring together people
who share a common interest to work for the continued well being of a breed. In
the Coton world we are particularly fortunate to have breeders and breed clubs
who are increasingly demonstrating a desire for real action to understand,
protect and enhance our beloved Cotons. Editor’s note: Over the years, Carolyn Brooke’s dogs have
been known for their sound constitutions, beauty and sweet dispositions—model
Cotons from a model breeder.
CMR Test —Canine Multi-focal
Retinopathy from the OptiGen web site ACQ March
2007 At this writing, a peer reviewed research paper
co-authored by researchers at U. of Pennsylvania, Cornell University and U. of
Saskatchewan in press and expected to be released in the next couple of months.
In the meantime, Optigen has published the information contained in this article
and asks for more samples. There are still questions to be answered: (1) Is
CMR a cause of Retinal Dysplasia? (2) Is PRA (progressive retinal atrophy) a
particularly severe form of CMR? (3) What is the incidence of CMR in Cotons —
Dr. Grahn has stated it may be as high as 25%. (4) At this time a blood test is
most reliable. Can a cheek swab test (much less intrusive and cheaper) be
developed? (5) What is the best breeding strategy — will the DNA test affect
ACVO’s decision to recommend “no breed” for this condition? Background: Canine Multi-focal Retinopathy (CMR) is a recently
identified recessively inherited eye disease known so far to affect the Mastiffs
(English, Bullmastiff, French mastiff or Dogue de Bordeaux), Great Pyrenees and
Coton de Tulear. Early clinical studies in 1998 by Dr. Bruce Grahn at the
University of Saskatchewan, Canada, first described CMR in the Great Pyrenees.
The condition observed in each of the named breeds at an ophthalmologist’s exam
includes numerous distinct (i.e. multi-focal) The disease generally develops in young dogs before 4
months and might progress slowly, might appear to heal, or might even appear and
then go away again. Some lesions disappear with no remaining sign, while some
lesions leave a wrinkled area – a fold. Some leave the lasting lesion of a
blister formation. Most dogs exhibit no noticeable problem with vision despite
their abnormal appearing retinas. And in almost all cases, CMR does not progress
significantly over time. The disease seems to have a consistent pattern among
the breeds identified so far, although lesions in the Coton de Tulear are often
more serious and seem to remain longer than in some of the other CMR-affected
breeds. In rare severe cases, the clinical diagnosis could be confused with
progressive retinal atrophy (PRA). The full range of clinical symptoms will
learned as more dogs are tested for their genetic status. The clinical presentation and pathology of CMR closely
resembles lesions of “Best vitelliform dystrophy”, a human disease with variable
clinical expression but usually with serious affects on central vision.
Identification of the gene mutation responsible for CMR was based on these
similarities. A mutation in the human VMD2 gene – Vitelliform Macular Dystrophy
2 Gene – causes dominantly inherited human Best Disease. Analysis of the canine
version of the VMD2 gene indicates that mutations in it cause CMR as a
recessively inherited canine condition. The normal form of the VMD2 gene
produces a protein named “bestrophin”. The bestrophin protein assembles, in the
cells of the retinal pigment epithelium, in a group of four or five units that
form a pore through which chloride ions pass. Our current understanding is that CMR is inherited in an
autosomal recessive pattern. This means the gene mutation responsible for CMR is
located on an autosome (that is, a chromosome that is not a sex chromosome) and
CMR disease results when the gene mutation is passed to the offspring by both
the mother and the father. It should be noted that the human disease that
mirrors CMR in dogs is an autosomal dominant disease with incomplete penetrance.
This means that sometimes, but not always, only one copy of the disease gene
needs to be present in order for the disease to be observed clinically. At this
point CMR in dogs is NOT considered to be an autosomal dominant disease however
as more animals are characterized genetically with the CMR test, it is possible
that we will find a similar form of inheritance as is seen in humans. There is complete concordance of the mutation with the
disease among affected dogs in the Mastiffs, Great Pyrenees and Coton de Tulear.
However, retinal dysplasia described in other breeds, for example in Labradors,
Samoyeds or English Springer Spaniels, is very distinct in comparison to CMR and
these conditions are not caused by the CMR mutation. Due to the abnormal appearance of the CMR-affected retina,
CERF, ACVO, ECVO and other ophthalmologist’s eye exam reports typically record
these multi-focal lesions as “retinal dysplasia” or “retinal folds”, to denote a
defect in formation of the retina. Such findings might disqualify the dog from
breeding. Presently CERF doesn’t list CMR as a specific condition, but does fail
a dog for “retinal dysplasia/retinopat The genetic test for CMR is valuable for identifying the
cause of a retinal deformation. Given the exact genetic diagnosis, the owner can
be reassured that there probably will be little or no vision loss due to this
condition. All the same, future cases of the condition can be prevented using
the CMR test as an information tool for breeding Genetic Testing: An exact diagnosis of this eye condition can be difficult.
Definitive clinical diagnosis might even change due to the changing appearance
of the retina as the dog ages. The CMR genetic test solves this problem
immediately since presence of the CMR gene mutation is detected by testing a DNA
sample. This result gives the owner immediate diagnostic information and aides
in making decisions for the affected dog and for breeding strategies. · The
OptiGen CMR test can be done reliably at any age – even in young pups, and the
result will be the same at any age, and will be the same whenever it is
repeated. · The
exact frequency of this disease, and of the gene mutation causing it, are not
known as yet. Data accumulated through genetic testing will help to provide that
information. · Tallies
of test results are updated and provided quarterly to national breed clubs. Breeding Strategies using the CMR Test: Benefits &
Limits to All Genetic Testing: The benefits of genetic disease testing are clear. With
informed breeding practices, breeders immediately can avoid producing CMR
affected pups, yet use any healthy dog in their program regardless of genetic
status. And since genetic testing can be done at any age, each dog’s genetic
status can be known even before clinical disease signs are recognized. Over
several generations of selection away from the disease gene, breeders can
eliminate a disease gene completely from their line. BUT, there are basic limits for any and all DNA
genetic tests. Whether a test is mutation-based or marker-based, it identifies
only the specific mutation being tested or the association between a specific
marker set and the disease. For example, a mutation test detects one specific
mutation in one specific gene. If there are several different mutations or
several different genes that can cause the same condition, one must discover and
then test for each mutation and each gene. It can be difficult or even
impossible to know how many mutations or how many marker sets exist in all the
members of a specific breed. As more and more dogs are tested, previously
unknown variations may come to light. Ordering the CMR Testing: The CMR test is done on a small sample of blood obtained by
your veterinarian. This allows the lowest risk of contamination of the sample
and added assurance of a match of the sample with the identified dog. Please
read the paragraphs below, and then read “Instructions and Information” to learn
about ordering a test, shipping a sample and prices.
Optigen charges $95 for a blood test to determine CMR. To
determine if there is a link between the gene responsible for CMR and the
condition of PRA (progressive retinal atrophy—which inevitably causes
blindness), Optigen request blood samples along with 4 generation pedigrees from
any Coton diagnosed with PRA. Because this program is still in the research
phase the testing is free. Breed clubs may sponsor genetic disease registries,
and ACC is working with OptiGen on this. You may contact OptiGen to send
samples at
www.optigen. Editor’s note: The more we know and the more we share, the
better off we all are—this is the real work of our breed club. Mongo, who lives with Ron
and Susan Hiskes, was one of the Cotons used in developing the test for CMR. He
is a CMR carrier . So is his daughter, “J”, a beautiful pet. All the other
dogs at Maison des Cotons are clear, and all, including Mongo, have passed CERF
tests. Mongo is now retired from our breeding program and spends his days
intimidating Cesar.
New information from OptiGen as of May 21, 2007 -- A cheek swab DNA test has proved to be effective which makes testing much easier. Owners can now collect DNA by swabbing the cheek with a foam swab and sending to OptiGen instead of having blood drawn at the vet. New information from Sue Pearce-Kelling of Optigen as of December 7, 2007. Dear Ron,
200
|
|
|